The Great Pool Debate: Solid vs. Mesh Inground Swimming Pool Covers

Ah, the age-old rivalry. Forget Team Edward vs. Team Jacob or Marvel vs. DC—this one’s for the pool owners. It’s Team Solid vs. Team Mesh, and if your pool cover isn’t pulling its weight this winter, it’s time to choose sides. Let’s settle the debate once and for all and find out: is your pool cover working hard, or hardly working?

Team Solid: The Overachiever

Solid covers are like the valedictorians of the pool-cover world. They’re dependable, protective, and go the extra mile to make sure your pool stays pristine all winter long. These covers are known for their ability to block everything—UV rays, rain, snow, debris, you name it. Not a single leaf or raindrop sneaks past a solid cover, making it the ultimate defender of your pool. Another perk is how well it protects your pool’s water chemistry. Since solid covers block UV rays, they prevent chlorine from breaking down, which means you’ll need fewer chemicals to rebalance things when spring rolls around. If you have a heated pool, solid covers are also great at retaining that precious warmth where it belongs—inside your pool, not floating away into the icy abyss of winter.

That being said, solid covers do have a reputation for being a bit high-maintenance. They’re heavy, and installing or removing one can feel like an unexpected gym session (at least you’re skipping leg day!). Water pooling on top of the cover is another common issue. Unless you’re prepared to deal with pumping that water off regularly, you may find yourself with a mini-lake sitting on your cover by the end of winter.

Solid covers are perfect for those who want their pools to stay spotless during the off-season. If you’re someone who prefers to open your pool in spring and be greeted by crystal-clear water with no surprises, a solid cover is the overachiever you want on your team (we highly recommend investing in a cover pump). 

Team Mesh: The Chill Minimalist

Mesh covers, on the other hand, are the laid-back friends of the pool-cover world. They’re lightweight, easy to handle, and happy to go with the flow (literally). One of their biggest selling points is convenience. Unlike solid covers, mesh covers are far easier to install and remove, making them a great option for anyone who doesn’t want to break a sweat. Additionally, you won’t have to worry about water pooling on top—mesh covers allow rain and snowmelt to drain right through, which eliminates the need for a cover pump. These covers are also durable, holding up well against harsh winter weather, so they’ll keep doing their job season after season.

However, their more relaxed nature comes with a few compromises. Since UV rays can pass through mesh covers, algae growth is more likely, and let’s be honest—nobody wants their pool to glow green in the spring. Rain and snowmelt also pass through the mesh, which can dilute your pool’s water chemistry, leaving you with a bigger job when it’s time to open your pool. While mesh covers do a great job of keeping out large debris, smaller particles like dirt and pollen can sneak through, making your spring clean-up a bit more involved.

Mesh covers are ideal for pool owners who prioritize convenience and don’t mind a little extra effort when reopening their pool. If you value simplicity and a lightweight, low-maintenance option, mesh covers are your go-to choice. 

So, Which Team Are You On?

When it comes to solid versus mesh covers, the decision ultimately depends on what matters most to you—total protection or ease of use. Solid covers are the overachievers that block everything and keep your pool’s water sparkling clean all winter long. Mesh covers, on the other hand, are the minimalist champions of convenience, making your life easier during installation and removal, but requiring a bit more effort come spring.

Still unsure? If your pool cover has seen better days or you need help deciding which type of cover is best for your pool, let the pros at Y.E.S. Contractors help. We offer cover inspections to make sure your current cover is doing its job and keeping your pool safe through the winter. If it’s time for an upgrade, we can also help you replace or upgrade your cover to something that better fits your needs.

When in Doubt, Call the Experts

If you’re not sure whether to join Team Solid or Team Mesh, don’t worry—we’ve got you covered (literally). Y.E.S. Contractors is here to help with everything from professional advice to installations and replacements. Don’t wait until spring to find out your pool cover wasn’t cutting it. Contact us today for a free cover inspection or a quote on a new cover. Your pool (and your sanity) will thank you.

So, are you Team Solid or Team Mesh? Drop your choice in the comments below and let the debate begin!